Identity Horror Stories

Browse identity horror stories from the Horror Story Archive.

My husband is against me putting my cat down.

A woman struggles with a heartbreaking decision about her sick cat, but a shocking truth changes everything she thought she knew.

I thought my wife's final confession would help me grieve. Instead, it destroyed every happy memory we'd ever shared.

I spent weeks searching for the person sneaking into my apartment. I never imagined the real break-in was happening inside my own mind.

I expected to confront my thoughts. I wasn't prepared to meet every version of myself that had ever existed.

Nobody remembers filming it.